Make the Environment Agency find out why our beaches fail – and fix it

by Nicola Hayden

Make the Environment Agency find out why our beaches fail – and fix it

by Nicola Hayden
Nicola Hayden
Case Owner
I’m Nicola, a sea swimmer from Kent. I’m crowdfunding to take legal action against the Environment Agency to fight for cleaner, safer beaches for everyone.
29
days to go
£360
donated of £1,000 target from 21 pledges
Donate now
Nicola Hayden
Case Owner
I’m Nicola, a sea swimmer from Kent. I’m crowdfunding to take legal action against the Environment Agency to fight for cleaner, safer beaches for everyone.
Donate now

Your donation will be returned if the campaign does not reach its initial target

Summary

I am bringing a judicial review in the High Court to make the Environment Agency meet its legal duties to fight pollution in our seas. 

This case is about two beaches, Dymchurch and Littlestone on Romney Marsh, Kent - but it could positively impact on beaches right across the country. Dymchurch and Littlestone are the only coastal bathing waters in Kent where people are advised not to swim - both of these beaches have ‘Poor’ ratings. The Environment Agency has been investigating pollution at Littlestone Beach since 1999; but shockingly, more than 25 years later, it still can’t say why the water quality continues to fail. 

The EAs duties apply to every bathing water in England rated ‘Poor’. In 2025 there were 32 with this rating. That includes many of the rivers and lakes local campaigners have fought to have designated in recent years. If the case establishes that the Agency aren't doing enough here, it could mean they have to go further at other beaches with poor ratings too.

Who am I?

My name is Nicola Hayden, a sea swimmer from Hythe in Kent. I worked in primary and early years education for years and ran a maintained nursery school and two Children's Centres before I retired. 

I swim along the Folkestone and Hythe coastline, including at Dymchurch and Littlestone. These are among the most beautiful stretches of the south coast: broad sands at low tide, open sea, and the wide skies of Romney Marsh behind. Families, dog walkers, paddleboarders and swimmers use them all year round.

There have been “no swim” warnings in place for three seasons at Littlestone and for two seasons at Dymchurch. I and other swimmers I know have cut back on how much we use these beaches. I have spent months at community meetings and writing letters trying to find out what the regulator is doing. I have not had proper answers, so I am taking legal action.

What is the problem?

Under the Bathing Water Regulations 2013, the Environment Agency has clear legal duties when a bathing water is rated Poor. It must identify the reasons why the water failed, and secure measures to tackle the causes of pollution. It must also give the public clear information and a real chance to take part.

What we have found:

  • The causes are still not identified. The Environment Agency's own action plans give only rough percentage estimates for broad categories of pollution source. At Dymchurch the sources are recorded as "unknown at present", and confidence in the estimates has not changed from one year to the next.
  • Key investigative work depends on funding bids. Microbial source tracking, a technique that can show whether pollution comes from humans, livestock or wildlife, is listed as "subject to securing funding".
  • The regulator relies heavily on the water company. It depends on Southern Water for modelling, for running local meetings and for the action tracker. It should be bringing its own independent judgement to bear.
  • The plans are not published. The action plans for these beaches were only released after freedom of information requests by my local MP Tony Vaughan – and the Environment Agency has not committed to publishing them.
  • Local evidence is not acted on. When local swimmers put a detailed analysis to the Environment Agency, linking storm overflow events to high bacteria readings, we were merely told it had been "noted".

The pollution may come from sewers, outfalls, drains, farmland or towns/ villages. That is exactly why the regulator needs to find out, and tell us.

What is the case asking for?

The claim asks the High Court to declare that the Environment Agency is failing to meet its legal duties, which include:

  1. identifying the reasons why Dymchurch and Littlestone fail, and act on the causes of pollution;
  2. giving the public clear and coherent information and a real say;
  3. exercising its own judgement, instead of relying on Southern Water to do its job.

A ruling would confirm what the law requires of the regulator - and that is the foundation for everything else: investigations funded and finished, causes named, plans published and acted on.

Why this case matters nationally

For every “Poor” bathing water in England. The same legal duties apply at every “Poor” bathing water. A High Court ruling on what the Agency must do to meet its duties, and on whether necessary work can wait on funding, would matter well beyond our beaches.

For communities that have won designation. In recent years communities across the country have campaigned to have their rivers and beaches designated. Of the waters designated since 2021, 19 were rated “Poor” in 2025. Designation is meant to bring in legal duties that protect swimmers. This case tests whether those duties actually lead the regulator to find and tackle the causes of pollution.

For the new regulator. The Government plans to replace today's fragmented system with a single water regulator. Until that happens, the Environment Agency holds the legal duties, and they must be met now. Whatever replaces it will need the independence, resources and openness to find the cause of pollution from every source. This case shows what happens when those are missing.

What your money pays for

I am raising £60,000 for my legal team's work, court fees and other disbursements, and the Environment Agency's legal costs. This is an environmental case, so my exposure to the other side's costs is capped; but if the case becomes more complex, I may need to raise more.

Where things stand

My solicitors, Leigh Day, sent a pre-action letter to the Environment Agency in June 2026. There have been months of correspondence since then, and a meeting with the Environment Agency in October. I was not reassured, so I have filed a claim for judicial review in the High Court. My barristers are David Wolfe KC and Barney McCay of Matrix Chambers.

Thank you

These beaches matter to everyone who loves this coast, and to anyone, anywhere, who wants to swim in clean water. Please give what you can and share this page. Every contribution helps hold the regulator to the law.

Recent contributions